Current:Home > InvestAlabama's Supreme Court rules frozen embryos are 'children' under state law -TradeWisdom
Alabama's Supreme Court rules frozen embryos are 'children' under state law
View
Date:2025-04-18 05:04:53
BIRMINGHAM, Ala. – A ruling by the Alabama Supreme Court has given fertilized eggs the same rights as children. The recent ruling has some fertility clinics claiming they will not be able to continue practicing in the state, while couples who need help getting pregnant are left wondering where they will turn for help building a family.
Residents of Alabama and the rest of the country might be shocked by the ruling, but many legal scholars were not.
"I was not surprised," said Jill Lens, a professor of law at the University of Arkansas and an expert in reproductive rights. "Alabama Supreme court has for a long time, enthusiastically applied wrongful death law to pregnancy losses and [if] it's a person the second it's in the womb – if it's a person, it's a person. I'm not sure why the location in a freezer would matter."
In other words, anyone who's been following Alabama's abortion debate should have seen it coming in a state where prosecutors have arrested pregnant women for engaging in behaviors like taking drugs that could be harmful to a fetus. Alabama outlaws all abortions, making no exceptions for cases of rape or incest.
While many other states have passed similar legislation, no other state has defined life as beginning at conception, which is essentially what this court ruling does.
No other state has given personhood rights to all fertilized eggs. And even in states that allow the prosecution of women who put the health of their fetuses at risk, most do not apply that prosecution statute to pregnancies before the 24th week. That is the age at which most doctors consider a fetus to be able to live outside the womb.
This case was brought before the state Supreme Court by three couples in Alabama who had frozen embryos being stored at a facility in Mobile. They had used IVF, or in vitro fertilization, to create embryos that were then frozen for them to be able to use at a later date. That's standard procedure in IVF clinics in the United States, where clinics prefer harvesting as many eggs at a time in order to increase the odds of getting even one egg that is healthy enough to be fertilized and put back into a woman's uterus.
What went wrong in this case pertains to the security of the hospital that was storing the frozen embryos. A random patient somehow gained access to the cryogenics lab, grabbed the embryos and dropped them, thus destroying them.
The three couples sued the hospital and a lower court ruled they were not entitled to damages because the frozen embryos were not people. The Alabama Supreme Court, however, ruled that they are indeed people, going so far as calling them "extrauterine children."
Alabama's Chief Justice, Tom Parker, wrote in the decision that destroying life would "incur the wrath of a holy God." Of nine state Supreme Court Justices, only one disagreed.
This case is not likely to be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court because this was the state's Supreme Court ruling based on a state law.
Critics have long urged the state legislature to spell out exactly who falls under the state's wrongful death statute. It's clear the state's Supreme Court says life begins at fertilization and that it doesn't matter whether that life is in a woman's uterus or in a freezer in a fertility clinic.
If Alabama lawmakers fail to define at what age a fertilized egg becomes a person, it could become a crime in Alabama to destroy frozen embryos. That could ultimately mean those embryos could be frozen forever, because it's not clear yet if those frozen embryos could be donated to other states or to science, because they have now been given the same protection as children.
The irony, here, is that the very lawsuit filed by the three couples who were upset when their embryos were destroyed may actually end up making it far more difficult for Alabmians who are struggling to conceive naturally.
veryGood! (8761)
Related
- San Francisco names street for Associated Press photographer who captured the iconic Iwo Jima photo
- Suni Lee 'on the right track' for Olympics after fourth-place finish at nationals
- No tiger found in Cincinnati so far after report of sighting; zoo tigers 'safe and sound'
- Cyndi Lauper announces farewell tour, documentary: 'Right now this is the best I can be'
- Warm inflation data keep S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq under wraps before Fed meeting next week
- Why Michael Crichton's widow chose James Patterson to finish his 'Eruption' book
- Minnesota prosecutor was reluctant to drop murder charge against trooper, but ultimately did
- Powerball winning numbers for June 3: Jackpot rises to $185 million
- Taylor Swift Eras Archive site launches on singer's 35th birthday. What is it?
- NYC couple says they reeled in $100,000 in cash stuffed inside safe while magnet fishing: Finders keepers
Ranking
- Bodycam footage shows high
- Felicity Actor Erich Anderson Dead at 67 After Private Cancer Battle
- Larry Allen, a Hall of Fame offensive lineman for the Dallas Cowboys, dies suddenly at 52
- Gossip Girl alum Taylor Momsen bit by a bat while performing in Spain: I must really be a witch
- Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
- Ben Affleck and Jennifer Lopez Tackle Breakup Rumors With PDA Outing
- Full transcript of Face the Nation, June 2, 2024
- Who will replace Pat Sajak on 'Wheel of Fortune?' Hint: He was 7 when Sajak began hosting.
Recommendation
Israel lets Palestinians go back to northern Gaza for first time in over a year as cease
Intelligence chairman says US may be less prepared for election threats than it was four years ago
Kentucky governor unveils rental housing projects for region still recovering from 2021 tornadoes
Wendy’s launches 'saucy' chicken nuggets in 7 flavors. Here’s how to try them first.
Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
Chinese spacecraft lands on far side of moon
Conservative University of Wisconsin regent resigns after initially refusing to step down
Biden prepares a tough executive order that would shut down asylum after 2,500 migrants arrive a day